It sounds to me like you know what you are doing, you are correct cocking the wrists up and down is for teaching purposes only.

As you say your set up is more y shaped looking face on with a flater left wrist, but you should still cock straight up, so when you are half way back the club should be natually tilting behind your body with the butt aiming at the ball.

Try taking the club back to 8 o clock the club face should be slightly shut"stop" at this position and cock straight up as if you are going to put the club on your right shoulder, "now" simply hold this position and turn your shoulders,............if you look into a mirror from behind you will see you are absoluley perfect...



Hope this helps.........let me know


Ian.